Capital ThesisIndependent equity research

Research desk

Independent equity research.

The business case, cash generation and the price that makes it work.Company analysis with dated evidence and explicit valuation scenarios.

Explore valuation scenarios
—Companies
—Research editions

Dated research. Source scenarios and entry thresholds remain as published. Current quotes are shown separately, with their source and observation time.

Reading the dates

Research library

Loading the archive

Connecting to market data.

Loading research

Opening the preserved report collection.

EXHIBIT / CROSS-COMPANY COMPARISON

Valuation & scenario analysis

Loading comparison

Compare potential return with the downside in view. The latest available price can be compared with each report’s original five-year scenarios. Loading price basis…

Weights and downside preference are house assumptions, not estimated probabilities. Table returns and scores are annualised; rank sensitivity shows the range under alternative weights and downside preferences.

Loading valuation inputs…

How the ranking works

A common five-year comparison

Each published bear, base and bull total-return CAGR is converted to a terminal wealth multiple: M = (1 + return / 100)⁵. Returns include cash distributions where the report models them; see each company’s source notes. These are rounded report inputs, not refreshed market estimates.

Updating the entry price

Latest-price mode holds the original five-year scenarios fixed and compares them with the latest eligible quote: M = reference price × (1 + report return / 100)⁵ / split factor / latest price. This is an entry-price sensitivity. Forecasts, modelled cash payouts and the five-year comparison horizon stay fixed; it is not a refreshed forecast or a return over the remaining time to an original target date. Past cash payouts are not removed. A refreshed report is needed for a new investment forecast. Split history is checked before repricing; other corporate actions can require a model review.

Recent public quotes are checked every 15 minutes and are not guaranteed real-time. Each price shows its source and observation time in US Eastern Time (ET). A green pulse means a recent quote no more than 20 minutes old; older last-available observations use a grey dot. Quotes fetched more than 20 minutes ago, observed more than four calendar days ago, or missing a verified share basis are excluded from latest-price rankings. Original-report mode remains a separate dated comparison.

The downside-sensitive score

We use the weighted harmonic mean of terminal wealth: H = 1 / (w_bear / M_bear + w_base / M_base + w_bull / M_bull), then score = (H^(1/5) − 1) × 100. This is the certainty-equivalent transformation for constant relative risk aversion of 2. It gives poor outcomes more influence than an arithmetic wealth blend. We selected this comparison preference; it is not calibrated to any reader, security or market.

Balanced weights are 25% / 50% / 25%; cautious weights are 50% / 40% / 10%. They describe the comparison exercise, not the likelihood of future outcomes. The resulting score is neither an expected return nor a guaranteed return. A modelled total-loss case produces a −100% limiting score.

See what changes the order

Base-case model return uses the report’s own terminal valuation and distributions. Fundamental compounding holds valuation multiples or the report’s market-to-NAV discount unchanged; this isolates compounding and does not measure cheapness by itself. In latest-price mode, the original-multiple case uses the report’s original terminal multiple against the updated entry price; it does not hold today’s multiple fixed. The score column always retains the downside-sensitive calculation, even when sorting another column.

Rank sensitivity compares four combinations: both weight sets with risk-aversion parameters 1 and 2. Parameter 1 uses a weighted geometric mean of wealth. A wide rank range signals dependence on our comparison assumptions; it is not a confidence interval.

Why this is not a PEG league table

PEG still depends on risk, payout and the earnings-growth definition. A common PEG rank would mix software, retail, payments, infrastructure and property/insurance forecasts with different earnings bases. The scenario approach exposes each report’s terminal valuation and downside instead of assuming those differences disappear.

Evidence and automatic updates

There is one selected report per company: latest research date, then full edition, then latest version. New reports enter the calculation when their embedded scenario inputs pass numerical and source-excerpt checks. Missing or invalid inputs leave that company unranked; an older score is not carried forward. Open pages refresh every minute while visible.

The original reports are AI-assisted and their underlying forecasts have not been independently audited. Three scenarios cannot measure all possible losses, interim drawdowns, liquidity, portfolio diversification or currency risk. Different report dates and assumptions reduce comparability. Review the source report and current evidence before drawing an investment conclusion.

Method references: NYU: constant relative risk aversion, §7.3; Damodaran: utility and certainty equivalents; Damodaran: PEG limitations. The theory supports the method; the selected parameters are our assumptions.