CAPITAL THESIS

Independent equity research · PYPL · full edition

PayPalMore payments. Less operating profit. A cash-per-share test.

We trace why payment growth is not reaching profit, separate reported cash from owner cash, and test whether disciplined buybacks can support a recovery investment.

Research date: 24 October 2026 · USD common equity · Reference price: USD 57.02 · Observation: 2026-10-23

Watchlist · cash-per-share recovery required

The investment decision

At $57.02, the base produces 15.3% a year over five years. A conditional 20% entry is $46.68 on earnings, or $40.50 using owner cash for the exit valuation. Neither works without healthier operations and cash-funded net retirement.

Q2 payment volume+10%Reported year-on-year growth
Q2 operating profit−5%GAAP, despite +5% revenue
TTM owner cash$4.804bnHouse bridge after awards and loan funding
Base five-year return15.3% p.a.Conditional total wealth, dividends held as cash

Edition update. 24 October Sydney edition; reference is the 23 October US regular close. Actuals remain through June ahead of the 27 October earnings date. Refines capitalised-award economics while preserving prior operating assumptions and archived reports.

01. More payments are not yet producing more operating profit

Research stance: watchlist; a conditional recovery case, not an automatic bargain. At the $57.02 reference, the base produces 15.3% annual total-wealth growth over five years. It needs 4% annual revenue growth, a recovery to a 19% operating margin, funded net share retirement and a 12x earnings exit. The conditional 20% hurdle entry is $46.68; valuing terminal owner cash at the same multiple lowers it to $40.50.

The attractive part is an established, profitable payments franchise at a modest earnings multiple. The uncomfortable part is that processing more money does not guarantee better economics. In Q2, total payment volume rose 10%, revenue rose 5%, and GAAP operating profit fell 5%. The investment succeeds if checkout relevance, monetisation and operating discipline improve cash earned per share. Buybacks can reinforce that outcome; they cannot manufacture a stronger product. [S1] [S4]

The reference is the 23 October 2026 regular close at 4 pm EDT, equivalent to 7 am on 24 October in Sydney. The separate $56.95 after-hours quote is not used. Financial actuals still end on 30 June; the next scheduled earnings date is 27 October. This is a refreshed assessment ahead of results, not a fabricated September-quarter update. [S3] [S6] [S7]

This edition preserves the earlier reports. It retains the 15 October operating scenarios and treasury execution-price schedule, updates the investor reference, and corrects compensation treatment: the earlier $1.001bn TTM figure is the cash-flow stock-compensation add-back, not the expense note. A separate $128m capitalised-award reserve is now included. The revised model therefore has slightly less cash for net repurchases. [S1] [S2] [S5]

02. Three payment activities, different economics

PayPal’s branded checkout connects a consumer wallet with a merchant transaction. Stored credentials, familiarity, buyer protection and a broad acceptance network can reduce checkout friction. The commercial advantage depends on conversion and repeat use being valuable enough for merchants to retain the button and pay its fees. A consumer can still choose a different wallet or card, while merchants can route payments among competing providers.

Venmo begins with consumer relationships and peer-to-peer use, then seeks to monetise them through merchant checkout, debit, transfers and other services. An increase in usage is not itself an increase in profit: incentives, fraud, customer support and funding costs still have to be paid. Braintree and the wider payment-service-provider activity process payments behind the scenes. Large merchants value reliability, authorisation performance, global reach and price, which can make growing processing volume less profitable per dollar than branded checkout. [S1] [S2]

Q2 2026 issuer TPV measureFX-neutral growthShare of total TPVInterpretation
Branded checkout online2%28%Slower than total platform growth
Venmo14%19%Includes P2P, checkout and debit
Payment service provider13%45%Includes Braintree and other merchant solutions

These are activity measures, not three additive revenue segments. Venmo overlaps other categories; do not sum the percentages into a segment mix or infer segment profit. The broader branded-experiences measure grew 6% on an FX-neutral basis because it also includes offline debit and tap-to-pay. Braintree’s own TPV growth was in the mid-teens. Those details explain why an upbeat platform-volume headline can coexist with only 2% online branded-checkout growth. [S6]

PayPal should not automatically receive a card-network valuation. Wallet choice, merchant negotiation, processing costs and consumer credit make its economics different from Visa or Mastercard. Device wallets, other processors and direct bank-payment routes compete for parts of the transaction. We use these comparisons to assess bargaining power; no stale peer-multiple table is presented as a live benchmark.

03. Where the extra activity is being absorbed

Q2 actuals; USD bn except EPS20252026Change
Revenue8.2888.682+4.8%
Transaction expense3.9684.385+10.5%
Transaction and credit losses0.4760.397−16.6%
Transaction-margin dollars3.8443.900+1.5%
GAAP operating income1.5041.427−5.1%
GAAP net income1.2611.104−12.5%
Diluted EPS$1.29$1.25−3.1%

The filing attributes transaction-expense growth partly to a higher Braintree mix, which has higher processing costs, and an unfavourable funding mix. Transaction revenue also grew more slowly than TPV because of product mix, co-marketing fees, foreign-exchange fees and partner incentives. In practical terms, more money passing through the system can leave relatively little extra money after payment-network and funding costs. [S1]

Transaction-margin dollars equal revenue less transaction expense and transaction/credit losses. The $3.900bn measure is useful for tracking what remains before other operating costs, but it is not net income. Excluding interest on customer balances, it grew about 3% to $3.619bn; lower interest income was a headwind. The issuer also cites investment in checkout and BNPL usage and the comparison with a prior non-recurring benefit. [S4] [S6]

GAAP operating margin fell to 16.4% from 18.1%. Non-transaction operating investment then consumed more of the modest transaction-margin increase. Adjusted operating income fell 8%, and adjusted EPS was $1.38, down 1%; those measures differ from the GAAP $1.25 EPS used in this report’s historical comparison. The distinction matters when discussing whether a result beat expectations or improved underlying earnings. [S4] [S6]

Buybacks explain much of the gap between net-income and EPS growth: diluted weighted-average shares fell from 977m to 882m. A smaller denominator cushioned a 12.5% fall in absolute net income to a 3.1% fall in reported EPS. That is a real per-share benefit, but should not be mistaken for growing operating profit. [S1]

04. Cash recovery and profit recovery are different tests

USD bn except diluted EPSFY2024FY2025H1 2025H1 2026
Revenue31.79733.17216.07917.035
Operating income5.3256.0653.0342.915
Net income4.1475.2332.5482.217
Diluted GAAP EPS$3.99$5.41$2.58$2.46
Operating cash flow7.4506.4162.0583.117
Cash capital expenditure0.6830.8520.4020.439
CFO less cash capex6.7675.5641.6562.678

Trailing figures are FY2025 plus H1 2026 less H1 2025: revenue $34.128bn, operating income $5.946bn, net income $4.902bn, CFO $7.475bn and cash capex $0.889bn. The four most recent reported quarterly diluted EPS figures sum to $5.29 ($1.30, $1.53, $1.21 and $1.25). This sum is a trailing per-share convention, not net income divided by today’s share count. Half-year figures are not annualised. [S1] [S2] [S6]

The H1 cash improvement is not entirely a new earnings engine. Cash taxes were $225m versus $837m, primarily because the final transition-tax instalment was paid in the earlier period. Partner receivable timing and lower annual incentive payments also helped cash conversion. These changes can improve liquidity without implying a repeatable growth rate for operating profit. [S1]

July management guidance raised adjusted EPS to approximately $5.38 for FY2026 while retaining a mid-single-digit decline in GAAP EPS from $5.41. It targeted around $15.6bn transaction-margin dollars, $6bn-plus adjusted FCF, $6bn buybacks and approximately $1bn capex. These are management forecasts, not the house model. Adjusted FCF removes certain BNPL sale-timing effects; it is not interchangeable with CFO less cash capex or our owner-cash proxy. [S4] [S6]

05. The $6.6bn cash headline needs a shareholder bridge

TTM through June 2026; USD bnAmountWhy it matters
CFO less cash capex6.586Reported cash-flow basis
Remove cash-flow employee-award add-back−1.001Retain expensed compensation as an economic cost
Reserve current capitalised employee awards−0.128New software assets funded with shares, not cash capex
Net held-for-investment loan funding−0.653Loan investment recorded below operating cash flow
Capital Thesis owner-cash proxy4.804Conservative economic measure, not company guidance

The stock-compensation figures require care. TTM expense disclosed in the compensation notes is $1.096bn; the cash-flow add-back is $1.001bn. They are different reported measures and must not be relabelled as identical. We subtract the actual add-back from CFO so that expensed compensation remains charged, then reserve the $128m of current capitalised awards that cash capex does not capture. The expense-note amount is not deducted again. [S1] [S2]

Held-for-sale BNPL originations and subsequent sales already run through operating cash flow. We do not charge that timing difference twice. The additional $653m loan deduction is the net funding in investing activities: $502m in FY2025 plus $431m in H1 2026 less $280m in H1 2025. It tests cash remaining after growing the held-for-investment loan book. Acquisitions and strategic investment purchases are outside this recurring proxy; future material deals would reduce distributable cash further. [S1] [S2]

Employee tax withholding and share-issuance proceeds are not separately charged after the compensation reserve; doing so would overlap the award economics. The method is a normalisation tool, not a claim that awards are settled for their accounting value or that all reserved cash is actually spent on offsetting shares. A materially different grant or share-price path would require re-underwriting dilution.

Using the last filed common count of 855.461m on 22 July with the $57.02 reference produces an illustrative equity value of $48.78bn. Headline FCF yield is 13.5%, versus 9.8% for the $4.804bn proxy. The common count is dated, not a new October filing, and these are economic yields rather than promised shareholder distributions. [S1] [S3]

Forward owner cash starts with GAAP-like net income, retaining ongoing expensed awards. It adds back D&A at 2.8% of revenue and charges cash capex at 2.6%, current capitalised awards at 0.4%, and net loan funding at 1.9%. Thus owner cash equals net income less 2.1% of revenue. Adding back historical asset amortisation before charging current capitalised investment avoids counting the same amortisation twice. The percentages are house normalisation assumptions anchored to the trailing statements, not precise company guidance.

06. Corporate liquidity is not the customer wallet balance

At June, the filing showed $13.530bn of corporate cash and investments excluding $1.7bn of strategic investments and $39.7bn of customer-related assets. Funded debt was about $13.4bn. Customer balances support withdrawal and settlement obligations; they cannot be treated as spare buyback cash. Even corporate liquidity has operational and regulatory uses, so the valuation gives no automatic credit for a large existing net-cash surplus. [S1]

June disclosed maturity / claimUSD bnScope
Notes due October 20261.250June schedule; date has passed, settlement not independently verified here
Notes due 20270.500Term debt principal
Paidy facility due February 20270.556Separate from the term-note maturity table
Notes due 20281.778Includes floating-rate and yen notes
Notes due 2029 / 20301.500 / 1.000Refinancing or repayment required
Later term notes6.700Longer-dated funding
Operating / finance leases0.810 / 0.011Separate contractual claims

The June note schedule totals $12.728bn face value. Commercial paper added $200m, and the Paidy facility was fully drawn. The company had access to wider revolving facilities, but contractual capacity is not cash already in the bank. The report does not pretend the June balance sheet is an October bank statement or silently assume that the October maturity created new equity value. [S1]

The model leaves the existing balance sheet broadly funded: net expense of $300m per year is retained before tax, and no existing liquidity surplus is added to terminal value. Operating lease costs stay in margins, so the lease liability is not subtracted again from this post-rent earnings valuation. Only newly retained model cash is credited, with zero interest income assumed. Debt refinancing rates, regulated cash requirements and acquisitions remain risks to that simplification.

07. Credit losses and capital returns can compete for the same cash

Quarterly transaction-and-credit-loss expense fell, yet the consumer annualised net charge-off rate rose from 3.6% to 4.8% and the merchant rate rose from 6.1% to 7.6%. Provisioning, recoveries, portfolio mix and actual defaults have different timing. Lower reported loss expense alone is therefore weak evidence that credit risk has disappeared. The model’s loan-funding reserve should be revisited if credit growth or losses accelerate. [S1]

In Q2, PayPal repurchased approximately 33m shares for $1.5bn; the trailing total was about 111m shares for $6bn. Gross repurchases do not equal net retirement because employee issuance and withholding affect the common count. The declared quarterly dividend was $0.14, payable on 25 September, with a 4 September record date. Annualising that rate gives $0.56, not a guaranteed future distribution. [S4]

The house model is less aggressive than simply carrying the $6bn repurchase headline forward. It pays dividends from owner cash first and spends only a defined fraction of the remaining cash on net retirement. Future awards are treated as a cash-equivalent reserve before this step; a second full dilution charge is not then added. This is an economic share model, not a prediction of the company’s exact GAAP diluted share calculation.

Cheap, cash-funded repurchases can compound per-share value. If the stock becomes expensive, the same spending retires fewer shares; if operating cash deteriorates, the budget shrinks. Debt-funded repurchases while checkout economics weaken would be a different and riskier thesis.

08. What the base case actually requires

Capital Thesis base, USD bn except shares/EPSYear 1Year 2Year 3Year 4Year 5
Revenue35.4936.9138.3939.9241.52
Operating margin17.0%17.5%18.0%18.5%19.0%
Normalised net income4.594.935.295.676.07
Owner cash3.844.154.484.835.20
Net repurchase budget2.682.933.193.473.77
Ending economic shares, million839.4797.8757.3718.0679.8

The 4% growth assumption is below current reported revenue growth but requires continued activity, monetisation and merchant retention. The operating margin begins at 17% and rises to 19%, compared with 16.4% in Q2 and 17.4% on a trailing basis. This is a recovery assumption: better mix and cost discipline must outweigh incentives, credit losses, platform investment and competitive pricing. It is not a mechanical extrapolation of the latest quarter.

The company’s technology-infrastructure programme includes workforce changes, data-centre exits and cloud migration. The filing estimates approximately $260m of annualised cost savings for that programme, with part reinvested and technology work extending toward 2028. We do not equate the gross saving with incremental net income or capitalise it separately on top of a higher margin. [S1]

All cases assume a 20% normalised tax rate and $300m annual other net expense. The starting 882m diluted-share proxy is deliberately above the 855.461m July legal common count. It preserves a conservative existing-claims allowance and comparability with the earlier model, rather than claiming to know October economic shares.

Base dividends begin at $0.56 and grow 5% annually; 80% of owner cash after dividends funds net repurchases. The treasury purchase-price schedule remains $56.10 × 1.12^year, or about $62.83 to $98.87. This is an exposed execution assumption retained from the prior model, not a share-price forecast. Changing the investor’s entry price does not secretly change that schedule. Unspent cash earns zero interest.

By year five, the base produces $6.071bn normalised net income and 679.8m ending economic shares. Run-rate terminal EPS is $8.93, whereas average-share EPS for that final year is $8.69. The valuation uses the ending-share run rate consistently. These five annual intervals approximate a 23 October 2026–23 October 2031 holding period, not exact fiscal-year forecasts.

09. Five-year shareholder outcomes need the whole cash path

House caseSales growthFinal op marginExit P/ETerminal priceCash dividendsAnnual return
Bear-2%12.5%8x$35.70$2.00-7.9%
Base4%19%12x$113.06$3.09+15.3%
Bull6.5%22%15x$201.12$3.29+29.1%

Bear five-year total-wealth CAGR: -7.9%. Base five-year total-wealth CAGR: 15.3%. Bull five-year total-wealth CAGR: 29.1%.

Bear assumes revenue declines 2% a year, operating margin falls to 12.5%, an 8x exit P/E, 40% of after-dividend owner cash spent on repurchases and a reduced $0.40 annual dividend. Base assumes 4% revenue growth, 19% margin and 12x. Bull assumes 6.5% revenue growth, 22% margin, 15x and 85% repurchase allocation, with dividend growth of 8%. The bull needs both substantial operating improvement and market willingness to pay more for earnings.

Terminal equity price = normalised terminal EPS × exit P/E + newly retained cash per ending share. Terminal wealth adds the investor’s cumulative dividends, held as cash with no reinvestment. Return = (terminal wealth / $57.02)^(1/5) − 1. No separate buyback yield is added: repurchases already affect the share count. Returns are nominal USD before investor taxes, fees and exchange-rate effects. These are conditional cases without probability weights, not price predictions.

The base terminal wealth is $116.16: $8.93 run-rate EPS at 12x, plus $5.90 newly retained cash and $3.09 cumulative dividends. Existing corporate liquidity is excluded. Retained cash earns no forecast income, so it is not also embedded as investment earnings in the P/E numerator.

Base five-year total-wealth CAGR without rerating: 13.0%. This holds the reference trailing P/E at 10.78x rather than the 12x base exit, with the same business, dividends, cash and shares. Multiple expansion contributes to the headline base, but is not its only source of return.

10. Earnings valuation needs a cash cross-check

The reference is about 10.8x the $5.29 reported trailing EPS sum and 10.6x management’s $5.38 adjusted FY2026 guidance. Those are different earnings bases. A PEG ratio would conceal the near-term GAAP decline and uncertain margin recovery, so it is not used as proof of cheapness.

At the same 12x terminal multiple, replacing base net income per share with owner cash per share produces 12.1% annual return and a $40.50 conditional 20% entry. It is a deliberately more cautious exit-multiple comparison, not a discounted-cash-flow valuation and not a second independent forecast of the business.

Owner-cash DCF discount rate2.5% perpetual growth valueTerminal share of value
10%$69.0972.4%
11%$60.7569.4%
12%$54.1866.6%

The owner-cash DCF is $60.75 at an 11% required return and 2.5% perpetual growth, with a $54–69 range at 12–10%. It discounts cash before dividends and net repurchases and divides by the starting 882m claims, rather than adding repurchase proceeds or terminal retained cash again. Existing liquidity receives no surplus credit. About 69% of value comes from the perpetuity, so the result is highly sensitive to durable cash conversion.

A roughly $61 DCF near the current price is not inconsistent with a much lower entry for a 20% hurdle: the required returns and terminal methods differ. The DCF is not a promise of 20% annual gains. Current positive earnings make P/E useful, but the cash model is necessary because compensation and credit investment consume part of what an earnings multiple capitalises.

One-at-a-time base stressAnnual return20% hurdle entry
Base15.3%$46.68
Treasury repurchase prices 25% higher14.0%$44.10
Operating margin 2 percentage points lower each year11.7%$39.80
Exit P/E 10x11.5%$39.50
Loan funding 1 percentage point of revenue higher14.5%$45.17

The sensitivity holds all other assumptions fixed. A higher repurchase cost, lower operating margin, lower exit multiple or heavier loan funding reduces value. These stresses can occur together, and downside can exceed the bear case. No current full broker-consensus model, peer-multiple dataset or options/short-positioning study was verified; none is invented to manufacture conviction.

11. What an entry price does—and does not—buy

The conservative owner-cash conditional entry for a 20% five-year CAGR is $40.50 per share, versus $46.68 under the earnings-multiple model. Both backsolves hold operating forecasts, future repurchase prices, net share paths, dividends and terminal retained cash fixed. Changing actual entry price does not automatically re-underwrite those assumptions.

The earnings-model calculation is $116.16 terminal wealth / 1.20^5 = $46.68. It uses unrounded model outputs and includes dividends held as cash. At $57.02, reaching the same 20% hurdle with the base operations and cash bridge would instead require an approximately 14.9x earnings exit, above the chosen 12x.

The website’s conservative entry field uses the owner-cash alternative; the scenario explorer retains the primary earnings-multiple cases. They answer different valuation questions and should not be mixed. A falling share price can coincide with worsening checkout relevance, credit quality or cash conversion, so neither entry number is an unconditional instruction to buy.

12. The next evidence is more useful than a takeover story

WindowEvidence to watchWhy it changes the thesis
27 October earningsBranded checkout, transaction-margin dollars and guidanceDoes growth translate to retained economics?
Next quarterly filingCash taxes, held-for-sale loan timing, investment-loan funding and awardsDoes owner cash persist beyond timing benefits?
Next 2–4 quartersNet share count and repurchase execution costsIs cash creating value for each remaining share?
2027 funding datesPaidy facility and note maturity handlingIs liquidity sufficient without sacrificing operations?
Through the infrastructure programmeSavings net of reinvestment and transition costsDoes the margin recovery become observable?

The 27 October date is announced on the company calendar and earnings presentation. The report does not assume the outcome or a new dividend declaration. A stronger thesis would show sustained branded-checkout acceleration, transaction-margin growth exceeding revenue growth, and operating margin moving toward the model while credit quality stabilises. Persistent 2% checkout growth with rising incentives and weak transaction margins would challenge the recovery. These are analyst monitoring criteria, not issuer promises. [S6] [S7]

Recent product distribution includes tuition payments, offline wallet use and an October partner announcement about cross-border payouts into PayPal and Venmo. These may widen engagement and monetisation, but no disclosed incremental profit from those launches is inserted into the model. Reach and product availability are not equivalent to earnings. [S7] [S8]

Market takeover commentary is excluded from the investment case. The reviewed current SEC submission list shows no later 8-K confirming a binding acquisition after the July results; that is a scoped evidence check, not proof that no private discussion exists. A rumoured premium is not cash available to shareholders. Underwrite the standalone business and revise only on verified terms. [S9]

The main risks are loss of checkout relevance, merchant pricing pressure, incentives and fraud costs, consumer and small-business credit deterioration, technology or cyber disruption, regulatory restrictions, and capital allocation that retires shares at poor prices. No personal portfolio circumstances are assumed. The purpose is an absolute-return research watchlist with explicit operating and cash conditions.

Financial exhibits

Exact observations accompany every chart. Actuals, management guidance and Capital Thesis assumptions are labelled separately; the chart shapes do not imply probabilities.

Chart 01 · Q2 2026 year-on-year percent change

More volume, less operating profit

Payment-processing scale is not the same as profit retained.

Reported / calculated growth
More volume, less operating profit (Q2 2026 year-on-year percent change). Exact figures in the table below.-10-5051015Payment volumeReported / calculated growth: 9.6723 Q2 2026 year-on-year percent change9.6723RevenueReported / calculated growth: 4.7539 Q2 2026 year-on-year percent change4.7539Transaction costReported / calculated growth: 10.5091 Q2 2026 year-on-year percent change10.5091Operating profitReported / calculated growth: -5.1197 Q2 2026 year-on-year percent change-5.1197
Exact values · Q2 2026 year-on-year percent change
ObservationReported / calculated growth
Payment volume9.6723
Revenue4.7539
Transaction cost10.5091
Operating profit-5.1197

Actuals. Transaction cost is transaction expense, not all operating expenses. Rounded narrative uses +10%, +5%, +11% and −5%. Sources: [S1] [S4]

Chart 02 · GAAP operating margin, percent

The latest quarter is below the base margin target

A 19% terminal operating margin requires a recovery.

Operating margin
The latest quarter is below the base margin target (GAAP operating margin, percent). Exact figures in the table below.05101520FY2024 actualOperating margin: 16.7469 GAAP operating margin, percent16.7469FY2025 actualOperating margin: 18.2835 GAAP operating margin, percent18.2835TTM June actualOperating margin: 17.4226 GAAP operating margin, percent17.4226Q2 2026 actualOperating margin: 16.4363 GAAP operating margin, percent16.4363
Exact values · GAAP operating margin, percent
ObservationOperating margin
FY2024 actual16.7469
FY2025 actual18.2835
TTM June actual17.4226
Q2 2026 actual16.4363

Annual, trailing and quarterly periods overlap; this exhibit compares levels, not additive periods or a sequential quarterly series. Sources: [S1] [S2]

Chart 03 · USD bn, signed bridge contribution

Reported free cash flow is not all available for owners

Compensation and loan funding reduce the economic cash proxy.

TTM June 2026
Reported free cash flow is not all available for owners (USD bn, signed bridge contribution). Exact figures in the table below.-202468Reported FCFTTM June 2026: 6.586 USD bn, signed bridge contribution6.586Award add-backTTM June 2026: -1.001 USD bn, signed bridge contribution-1.001Capitalised awardsTTM June 2026: -0.128 USD bn, signed bridge contribution-0.128Loan fundingTTM June 2026: -0.653 USD bn, signed bridge contribution-0.653Owner cashTTM June 2026: 4.804 USD bn, signed bridge contribution4.804
Exact values · USD bn, signed bridge contribution
ObservationTTM June 2026
Reported FCF6.586
Award add-back-1.001
Capitalised awards-0.128
Loan funding-0.653
Owner cash4.804

First bar less the three costs equals the final bar; do not sum the final total again. Capital Thesis owner-cash proxy, not GAAP or issuer guidance. Sources: [S1] [S2]

Chart 04 · Annualised net charge-off rate, percent

Net charge-off rates increased

Lower provision expense alone does not establish better credit quality.

ConsumerMerchant
Net charge-off rates increased (Annualised net charge-off rate, percent). Exact figures in the table below.02468Q2 2025Consumer: 3.6 Annualised net charge-off rate, percent3.6Merchant: 6.1 Annualised net charge-off rate, percent6.1Q2 2026Consumer: 4.8 Annualised net charge-off rate, percent4.8Merchant: 7.6 Annualised net charge-off rate, percent7.6
Exact values · Annualised net charge-off rate, percent
ObservationConsumerMerchant
Q2 20253.66.1
Q2 20264.87.6

Issuer quarterly annualised rates on average daily receivables, excluding fraud; portfolios are not economically identical. Sources: [S1]

Chart 05 · USD bn; Capital Thesis estimates

The base funds net retirement after economic costs

Buybacks are limited by owner cash after dividends.

Owner cashNet repurchase budget
The base funds net retirement after economic costs (USD bn; Capital Thesis estimates). Exact figures in the table below.0123456Year 1 houseOwner cash: 3.8417 USD bn; Capital Thesis estimates3.8417Net repurchase budget: 2.6782 USD bn; Capital Thesis estimates2.6782Year 2 houseOwner cash: 4.1526 USD bn; Capital Thesis estimates4.1526Net repurchase budget: 2.9273 USD bn; Capital Thesis estimates2.9273Year 3 houseOwner cash: 4.4819 USD bn; Capital Thesis estimates4.4819Net repurchase budget: 3.1915 USD bn; Capital Thesis estimates3.1915Year 4 houseOwner cash: 4.8305 USD bn; Capital Thesis estimates4.8305Net repurchase budget: 3.4716 USD bn; Capital Thesis estimates3.4716Year 5 houseOwner cash: 5.1994 USD bn; Capital Thesis estimates5.1994Net repurchase budget: 3.7685 USD bn; Capital Thesis estimates3.7685
Exact values · USD bn; Capital Thesis estimates
ObservationOwner cashNet repurchase budget
Year 1 house3.84172.6782
Year 2 house4.15262.9273
Year 3 house4.48193.1915
Year 4 house4.83053.4716
Year 5 house5.19943.7685

House forecast. Owner cash retains award costs and funds cash capex and loan growth; 80% of remaining cash after base dividends funds net retirement. Sources: [S1] [S2] [S5]

Chart 06 · Percent annual total-wealth return

The base does not clear 20% at the reference price

Different margins, growth and exit multiples create a wide range.

Five-year CAGR
The base does not clear 20% at the reference price (Percent annual total-wealth return). Exact figures in the table below.-100102030Bear houseFive-year CAGR: -7.9401 Percent annual total-wealth return-7.9401Base houseFive-year CAGR: 15.2934 Percent annual total-wealth return15.2934Bull houseFive-year CAGR: 29.0905 Percent annual total-wealth return29.0905
Exact values · Percent annual total-wealth return
ObservationFive-year CAGR
Bear house-7.9401
Base house15.2934
Bull house29.0905

Conditional model, $57.02 entry, dividends held as cash, net share retirement included. Nominal USD before investor costs; no scenario probabilities. Sources: [S1] [S2] [S3] [S5]

Source register and research basis

Evidence checked for this edition on 24 October 2026. Dates below identify source vintages. Company guidance and house scenarios are conditional; source links and the downloadable model allow the assumptions to be inspected.

S3 · Stock Analysis PYPL price snapshot

23 October 2026, 4 pm EDT regular close · $57.02 reference; separate $56.95 after-hours observation excluded. Live page changes; local snapshot retained.

https://stockanalysis.com/stocks/pypl/
S7 · PayPal investor relations calendar and news

Accessed 24 October 2026 · 27 October Q3 earnings event and primary product announcements. Calendar date checked against presentation.

https://investor.paypal-corp.com/home/
S9 · SEC PayPal filing submissions index

Accessed 24 October 2026 · Scoped recent-filings check; no later 8-K in the downloaded recent list after July results. Does not establish absence of private talks.

https://data.sec.gov/submissions/CIK0001633917.json